Season 2

E1. Vic Michaelis

Sep 18, 2024 · 36m

The Pretty Gay Season 2 premiere! Catherine McCafferty welcomes the incredibly funny Vic Michaelis. Is Catherine off the market now?!

E2. Lorena Russi

Oct 2, 2024 · 35m

Sparks fly as Catherine confuses, flirts, and falls in love with fantastic soccer player turned comedian Lorena Russi.

E3. Jordan Myrick

Oct 16, 2024 · 44m

Catherine may have colitis and Jordan Myrick may be a bit of a chef, but that won't stop these two from falling in love.

E4. Grant O'Brien

Oct 30, 2024 · 45m

Catherine sits down with comedian and on-screen bartender Grant O'Brien for what can only be described as a very bisexual date.

E5. Jiavani

Nov 13, 2024 · 41m

Watch Catherine fall in love with the supremely talented comedian, improviser, and Dalmatian Jiavani.

E6. Anna Garcia (2)

Nov 27, 2024 · 41m

Anna Garcia is back for a second date. It’s fun, it’s spicy, dare we say she flies Catherine’s heart straight to the moon?

E7. Angela Giarratana

Dec 11, 2024 · 44m

Catherine sits down with comedian and internet sensation Angela Giarratana as the two of them hard launch their new relationship on Instagram.

E8. Erika Ishii

Dec 25, 2024 · 43m

Happy HoliGay! This week Catherine goes on a date with the hilarious voice actor, host, and D20 star Erika Ishii! There are swords, snakes, and a brief PSA to Vin Diesel.

E9. Rachel Scanlon

Jan 8, 2025 · 48m

Comedian and very tall person Rachel Scanlon joins us on this spicy episode filled with Veggie Tales, bull riding, and lots of flirty eye contact!

E10. Maddie Zahm

Jan 22, 2025 · 37m

Singer and all-around sweetie Maddie Zahm sits down to date Catherine on this anxiously attached episode of Pretty Gay! Pre-save Maddie's new single Sheets if you like sapphic love songs and you know you do!

E11. Bri Giger

Feb 5, 2025 · 50m

Comedian, actress, and DJ Bri Giger joins Catherine on this week's date! Watch them flirt with snacks, discuss kinks, and uncover an unlikely bond over mayonnaise.

E12. Kendahl Landreth

Feb 19, 2025 · 45m

The absolutely hilarious comedian and content superstar Kendahl Landreth joins Catherine on this week's Pretty Gay. They laugh, they flirt, they talk about having dead dads- classic first date stuff. Check out Kendahl's podcast with former guest and her future wife Jordan Myrick called Happy Wife Happy Life!

E13. Harper-Rose Drummond

Feb 26, 2025 · 40m

Please enjoy actress and comedian Harper-Rose as she takes Catherine on a wild date filled with giggles, trauma bonding, and a tough game of What's the Gayest?

E14. Alex Song-Xia

Mar 19, 2025 · 37m

Watch Catherine fall in love with comedian, actor, and writer Alex Song-Xia over a particularly spicy game of role-play!

E15. Pallavi Gunalan (2)

Apr 2, 2025 · 47m

Welcoming back: the extraordinary Pallavi Gunalan for our Season 2 Finale!! Watch as they create discourse, learn about each other's exes, and ultimately hard launch ON MAIN. Follow Pallavi Gunalan on socials for their stand-up dates and projects!